Baker Newby Black & White Logo
  • Our Firm
    • Our Team
    • What’s New
    • Our Community
  • Business Services
    • Agriculture
    • Business Financing
    • Business Structures
    • Purchases, Sales and Other Commercial Transactions
    • Commercial Dispute Resolution
    • Construction Law
    • Contracts and Other Legal Documents
    • Employment Law
    • Land Transactions
    • Indigenous Law
    • Privacy Law
    • Succession Planning
  • Dispute Resolution
    • Negotiation Services
    • Mediation Services
    • Arbitration Services
    • Litigation Strategy
    • Parenting Coordinator
  • Personal Services
    • Family Law
    • Estate and Wealth Preservation Law
    • Real Estate Law
    • Employment Law
    • Estate Litigation
    • Criminal Defence Law
    • Personal Injury Law
    • Privacy Law
    • Insurance Law
    • Disability Insurance
    • Slip and Fall
  • Blog
  • Mediators
  • Career Opportunities
Menu
  • Our Firm
    • Our Team
    • What’s New
    • Our Community
  • Business Services
    • Agriculture
    • Business Financing
    • Business Structures
    • Purchases, Sales and Other Commercial Transactions
    • Commercial Dispute Resolution
    • Construction Law
    • Contracts and Other Legal Documents
    • Employment Law
    • Land Transactions
    • Indigenous Law
    • Privacy Law
    • Succession Planning
  • Dispute Resolution
    • Negotiation Services
    • Mediation Services
    • Arbitration Services
    • Litigation Strategy
    • Parenting Coordinator
  • Personal Services
    • Family Law
    • Estate and Wealth Preservation Law
    • Real Estate Law
    • Employment Law
    • Estate Litigation
    • Criminal Defence Law
    • Personal Injury Law
    • Privacy Law
    • Insurance Law
    • Disability Insurance
    • Slip and Fall
  • Blog
  • Mediators
  • Career Opportunities
Contact Us

Chilliwack Office
P.O. Box 390, 9259 Main Street, Chilliwack, BC V2P 6K2
(604) 792-1376 

Abbotsford Office
200 – 2955 Gladwin Rd,
Abbotsford BC V2T 5T4
(604) 852-3646

©2020 Baker Newby
Full-Service Lawyers.
All rights reserved.

Baker Newby Black & White Logo
  • Our Firm
    • Our Team
    • What’s New
    • Our Community
  • Business Services
    • Agriculture
    • Business Financing
    • Business Structures
    • Purchases, Sales and Other Commercial Transactions
    • Commercial Dispute Resolution
    • Construction Law
    • Contracts and Other Legal Documents
    • Employment Law
    • Land Transactions
    • Indigenous Law
    • Privacy Law
    • Succession Planning
  • Dispute Resolution
    • Negotiation Services
    • Mediation Services
    • Arbitration Services
    • Litigation Strategy
    • Parenting Coordinator
  • Personal Services
    • Family Law
    • Estate and Wealth Preservation Law
    • Real Estate Law
    • Employment Law
    • Estate Litigation
    • Criminal Defence Law
    • Personal Injury Law
    • Privacy Law
    • Insurance Law
    • Disability Insurance
    • Slip and Fall
  • Blog
  • Mediators
  • Career Opportunities
Menu
  • Our Firm
    • Our Team
    • What’s New
    • Our Community
  • Business Services
    • Agriculture
    • Business Financing
    • Business Structures
    • Purchases, Sales and Other Commercial Transactions
    • Commercial Dispute Resolution
    • Construction Law
    • Contracts and Other Legal Documents
    • Employment Law
    • Land Transactions
    • Indigenous Law
    • Privacy Law
    • Succession Planning
  • Dispute Resolution
    • Negotiation Services
    • Mediation Services
    • Arbitration Services
    • Litigation Strategy
    • Parenting Coordinator
  • Personal Services
    • Family Law
    • Estate and Wealth Preservation Law
    • Real Estate Law
    • Employment Law
    • Estate Litigation
    • Criminal Defence Law
    • Personal Injury Law
    • Privacy Law
    • Insurance Law
    • Disability Insurance
    • Slip and Fall
  • Blog
  • Mediators
  • Career Opportunities

Court of Appeal Refuses to Set Aside Jury Award of $2,000

Personal Injury Law
September 21, 2011
Loading...

Court of Appeal Refuses to Set Aside Jury Award

SMAGH V. BUMBRAH, 2011 BCCA 281 (“SMAGH”)

In the case of SMAGH V. BUMBRAH, 2011 BCCA 281 (“SMAGH”), the Court considered an appeal by the Plaintiff of a trial decision in which a Supreme Court jury awarded the Plaintiff $2,000 for non-pecuniary damages and nothing for past loss of income, loss of future earning capacity, or cost of future care. The collision which gave rise to the proceedings was a rear-end collision that resulted in the Plaintiff claiming neck and back injuries.

In SMAGH, the Plaintiff argued that the trial judge erred in law in three ways (at para. 4):

 [1.]     BY FAILING TO DIRECT A MISTRIAL AND ORDER THAT THE TRIAL PROCEED IN THE ABSENCE OF THE JURY;

[2.]     BY PERMITTING CLINICAL RECORDS TO GO TO THE JURY, IN THE ABSENCE OF VIVA VOCE TESTIMONY FROM THE MAKER OF THE DOCUMENTS AND IN THE ABSENCE OF SUFFICIENT DIRECTION TO THE JURY AFTER THE RECORDS WERE PUT TO THE JURY;

[3.]     BY ALLOWING COUNSEL FOR THE RESPONDENT (DEFENDANT) TO MAKE INAPPROPRIATE STATEMENTS BEFORE THE JURY IN HIS CLOSING ARGUMENT, WITHOUT DIRECTION OR CAUTION TO THE JURY.

With respect to the first ground of appeal, the Plaintiff objected to the fact that during cross-examination of the Plaintiff’s general practitioner, counsel for the Defendant put clinical records to the witness that were from another doctor who had treated the Plaintiff before the collision. The Plaintiff objected to this aspect of the cross-examination because the clinical records referred to “chronic neck pain” and “myofascial syndrome” and constituted inadmissible hearsay and opinion evidence. At trial, the judge held that although the evidence was inadmissible, the Plaintiff had not met the heavy burden imposed on an applicant asking that the jury be dismissed and the trial proceed with judge alone. The trial judge held that the relevant test was whether the “impugned remarks are of such a nature that nothing the trial judge could say to the jury would dispel the remarks from their minds such that the applicant could receive a fair trial” (at para. 6). The trial judge held that a strict warning to the jury was sufficient to ensure that the inadmissible evidence was not considered. The Court of Appeal upheld the trial judge’s decision and rejected the Plaintiff’s submissions on the first ground of appeal as it found that the Plaintiff had not met the burden of showing that “the judge erred in principle or was clearly wrong in deciding that a warning to the jury was sufficient to prevent prejudice” (at para. 10).

The second ground of appeal in SMAGH was whether the trial judge erred in allowing the Plaintiff’s redacted pre-accident clinical records to be admitted without explaining them more clearly to the jury in light of their “confusing” and partially “illegible” nature. However, the Court of Appeal rejected this ground of appeal because the records were initially admitted into evidence by consent and without the Plaintiff requesting any limits on the way the records could be used at trial.

Finally, all parties conceded that the following statement to the jury by defence counsel was inappropriate in that it tended to suggest that the defence counsel was somehow working alongside the court and jury in testing the validity of the Plaintiff’s case (at para. 15):

I’M HERE — I START OFF NORMALLY LIKE THIS, I’M ON BEHALF OF THE DEFENDANT MR. BUMBRAH. YOU KNOW THAT. I’M HERE WITH MY COLLEAGUE AND WE ARE DEFENDING THE CASE. WE ARE CHARGING THE PLAINTIFF’S EVIDENCE. THAT’S OUR ROLE. THAT’S OUR JOB. WE’RE DOING IT ON YOUR BEHALF AND ON HIS LORDSHIP’S BEHALF AND ON BEHALF, JUST AS MY LEARNED FRIENDS ON BEHALF OF THE PLAINTIFF ARE TRYING TO PRESENT EVIDENCE TO YOU. THAT’S OUR JOB. THAT’S THEIR JOB.

However, the Court of Appeal agreed with the trial judge’s opinion that the jury was aware of the respective roles of the parties, and rejected the appropriateness of comments made by defence counsel at trial as a ground of appeal.

Ultimately, the Court in SMAGH upheld the trial decision, dismissing all three grounds of appeal.

Have a comment? We would welcome your comments directly. lzacharias@www.bakernewby.com

Related Posts

Get a Grip On Winter

With shorter days upon us and cooler temperatures in the forecast, winter is fast approaching. Before we know it, snow

Read More »
November 5, 2018

News Release: Truth and Reconciliation in Practice

Truth and Reconciliation Commission In late 2015, the Benchers of the Law Society of British Columbia have unanimously agreed that

Read More »
October 12, 2016

Waxing your board: Liability on the slopes

This past winter has been one of the best in recent memory for snow conditions on the local mountains. While

Read More »
October 12, 2016
Baker Newby Black & White Logo

Get our newsletter delivered to your inbox.

How Can We Help You?

Get Connected

Facebook Twitter Youtube Linkedin-in Instagram
Contact Us
Search
Close

© 2022 Baker Newby Full-Service Lawyers. All rights reserved. 

Privacy Policy | Designed by Jelly Digital Marketing & PR