Baker Newby
  • Our Firm
    • Our Team
    • What’s New
    • Our Community
    • Our History
  • Business Services
    • Agriculture
    • Business Financing
    • Business Structures
    • Purchases, Sales and Other Commercial Transactions
    • Commercial Dispute Resolution
    • Construction Law
    • Contracts and Other Legal Documents
    • Employment Law
    • Land Transactions
    • Indigenous Law
    • Privacy Law
    • Succession Planning
  • Dispute Resolution
    • Negotiation Services
    • Mediation Services
    • Arbitration Services
    • Litigation Strategy
    • Parenting Coordinator
  • Personal Services
    • Family Law
    • Estate and Wealth Preservation Law
    • Real Estate Law
    • Employment Law
    • Estate Litigation
    • Criminal Defence Law
    • Personal Injury Law
    • Privacy Law
    • Insurance Law
    • Disability Insurance
    • Slip and Fall
  • Blog
  • Mediators
  • Career Opportunities
  • Our Firm
    • Our Team
    • What’s New
    • Our Community
    • Our History
  • Business Services
    • Agriculture
    • Business Financing
    • Business Structures
    • Purchases, Sales and Other Commercial Transactions
    • Commercial Dispute Resolution
    • Construction Law
    • Contracts and Other Legal Documents
    • Employment Law
    • Land Transactions
    • Indigenous Law
    • Privacy Law
    • Succession Planning
  • Dispute Resolution
    • Negotiation Services
    • Mediation Services
    • Arbitration Services
    • Litigation Strategy
    • Parenting Coordinator
  • Personal Services
    • Family Law
    • Estate and Wealth Preservation Law
    • Real Estate Law
    • Employment Law
    • Estate Litigation
    • Criminal Defence Law
    • Personal Injury Law
    • Privacy Law
    • Insurance Law
    • Disability Insurance
    • Slip and Fall
  • Blog
  • Mediators
  • Career Opportunities
Contact Us

Chilliwack Office
9259 Main Street
Chilliwack, BC V2P 4M8
(604) 792-1376

Abbotsford Office
200 – 2955 Gladwin Rd,
Abbotsford BC V2T 5T4
(604) 852-3646

Add Your Heading Text Here

Baker Newby
  • Our Firm
    • Our Team
    • What’s New
    • Our Community
  • Business Services
    • Agriculture
    • Business Financing
    • Business Structures
    • Purchases, Sales and Other Commercial Transactions
    • Commercial Dispute Resolution
    • Construction Law
    • Contracts and Other Legal Documents
    • Employment Law
    • Indigenous Law
    • Land Transactions
    • Privacy Law
    • Succession Planning
  • Dispute Resolution
    • Negotiation Services
    • Mediation Services
    • Arbitration Services
    • Litigation Strategy
    • Parenting Coordinator
  • Personal Services
    • Family Law
    • Estate and Wealth Preservation Law
    • Real Estate Law
    • Employment Law
    • Estate Litigation
    • Criminal Defence Law
    • Personal Injury Law
    • Privacy Law
    • Insurance Law
    • Disability Insurance Law
    • Slip & Fall Law
  • Blog
  • Mediators
  • Career Opportunities
  • Our Firm
    • Our Team
    • What’s New
    • Our Community
  • Business Services
    • Agriculture
    • Business Financing
    • Business Structures
    • Purchases, Sales and Other Commercial Transactions
    • Commercial Dispute Resolution
    • Construction Law
    • Contracts and Other Legal Documents
    • Employment Law
    • Indigenous Law
    • Land Transactions
    • Privacy Law
    • Succession Planning
  • Dispute Resolution
    • Negotiation Services
    • Mediation Services
    • Arbitration Services
    • Litigation Strategy
    • Parenting Coordinator
  • Personal Services
    • Family Law
    • Estate and Wealth Preservation Law
    • Real Estate Law
    • Employment Law
    • Estate Litigation
    • Criminal Defence Law
    • Personal Injury Law
    • Privacy Law
    • Insurance Law
    • Disability Insurance Law
    • Slip & Fall Law
  • Blog
  • Mediators
  • Career Opportunities

Pension Division Issues in Family Law

Family Law
August 26, 2013
Loading...

A pension cheque signing in family law court

In Jarman v. Jarman, 2011 BCSC 1155, the Claimant was the former wife of the Respondent who was a retired Air Canada Pilot. The Respondent had an interest in two pension plans with Air Canada: the Air Canada Pension Plan for Pilots, and a Supplemental Retirement Plan (the “SRP”). Air Canada had a policy that no distribution would be made directly from the SRP and no direct settlement would be possible from the SRP.

The principal issue before the Court was whether the SRP was subject to an order under Part VI of the FRA, specifically s. 77 which would require Air Canada to divide and pay a portion of the SRP to each spouse, or whether Air Canada could make all payments of the SRP to the Respondent who would then bear the burden of paying the Claimant her share of the proceeds.

Air Canada’s position was that the Court did not have the jurisdiction to make an order under the FRA since Air Canada is a federally regulated employer, and that the SRP as a supplemental pension is not governed by the Pension Benefits Standards Act, 1985, R.S.C. 1985, c. 32 (2nd Supp. (“PBSA”).

Air Canada further claimed that it was administratively impossible to pay the proceeds of the SRP directly to the Claimant until certain administrative changes were made, which may be possible to do by October or November 2011.

Section 4 of the PBSA provides that the statute “applies in respect of pension plans”. The term “Pension Plan” is defined in section 4(2) to include a “supplemental pension plan”. This includes the SRP.

Section 25(1) of the PBSA defines provincial property law to include property division on marital breakup, and makes pension plan benefits “subject to the applicable provincial property law”. The Court found that this made the SRP subject to applicable provincial law.

Section 77(1) of the FRA states that, on division, the Spouse is entitled to receive “from the plan a proportionate share of the benefits paid under the pension”. The Court specifically noted that the section stated receipts from the plan and not receipts from the spouse.

As to Air Canada’s further argument, administrative difficulties cannot prevent the application of provincial law.

In the result, the Court found that Air Canada must divide the SRP and pay the Claimant her share of the SRP directly.

Related Posts

Chilliwack Law Courts

A Guide to Hear the Child, Views of the Child, and Full Section 211 Reports in BC Family Law

Which Child-Voice Report Do You Need? A Guide to Hear the Child, Views of the Child, and Full Section 211

Read More »
May 7, 2025
Collaborative Family Law

Collaborative Family Law – An Alternative Approach

By Pamela Bakshi When parties make the difficult decision to separate, unfortunately people then have the added layer of stress

Read More »
April 9, 2025
Baker Newby Pen

Tracing Excluded Property: Lessons from Mills v. O’Connor

By: Abigail Falk Mr. Mills and Ms. O’Connor were married for over 20 years. During the marriage, Mr. Mills inherited

Read More »
February 20, 2025
Baker Newby

Get our newsletter delivered to your inbox.

How Can We Help You?

Get Connected

Facebook Twitter Youtube Linkedin-in Instagram
Contact Us

© 2023 Baker Newby Full-Service Lawyers. All rights reserved. 

Privacy Policy | Designed by Jelly Digital Marketing & PR