Jason Filek has over 20 years of experience as a litigation lawyer, and takes a practical, efficient and reasonable approach to dispute resolution. He believes strongly in the use of alternate dispute resolution, but is equally comfortable in the courtroom. With a background prosecuting criminal cases and defending insurance claims, he brings broad Trial experience to his work.
In this article, Jason explores the surprising legal protections behind the middle finger—breaking down how this gesture is viewed in Canadian and U.S. law, and what it really means for free expression.
It was a humid day in Toronto when a police officer found herself in a bit of hot water—not for enforcing the law, but for giving someone the middle finger. Yes, the iconic “bird” was aimed at a citizen who had the audacity to question the officer’s parking choices. This bird flip was caught on video and went viral, so you may have seen it. The incident, though seemingly trivial, opens the door to an interesting question: can flipping the bird get you in trouble with the law?
For more context, here’s a news segment covering the incident:
This video provides additional details about the confrontation and the subsequent investigation.
The Bird Takes Flight in Canada
In Canada, flipping someone off is not just a display of frustration or a heat-of-the-moment gesture—it’s a “God-given, Charter-enshrined right”. Yes, you read that right. In a 2023 decision, a Quebec judge ruled that giving the middle finger is protected as part of freedom of expression under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. The case involved a Montreal-area man, who found himself in court for flipping off his neighbor during a heated dispute. The judge, however, was quick to throw out the case, noting that while the gesture might not be polite, it certainly is not criminal.“To be abundantly clear, it is not a crime to give someone the finger,” the Judge wrote, adding that the gesture is part of a Canadian’s fundamental right to free expression. Essentially, in Canada, as long as you’re not combining that gesture with threats or physical violence, you are free to express your disdain in finger-form.
America: Land of the Free, Home of the Bird
Crossing the border into the U.S., the middle finger has also enjoyed its fair share of courtroom drama, albeit with a bit more flair. In one of the most famous cases, a Michigan woman raised her middle finger to a police officer after receiving a ticket. In response, the officer pulled her over again and upgraded the ticket to a more serious violation. The Court swiftly ruled in her favor, concluding that flipping the bird is protected by the First Amendment of the US Constitution.
This ruling echoes a consistent theme in U.S. jurisprudence: while the middle finger may not win you friends, it is firmly protected by the First Amendment, as long as it doesn’t cross into “fighting words” territory or incite violence. In 2013, a New York man was arrested for giving the bird to a cop. The court again found the arrest unjustified, ruling that the gesture alone does not constitute disorderly conduct.
In Conclusion: The Finger Stands Tall
Whether you’re in Canada or the U.S., the middle finger serves as more than just a rude gesture; it has emerged as a symbol of free expression and personal frustration. In Canada, courts have reinforced the idea that the gesture is not just an act of defiance but a legitimate form of communication, protected by the Charter of Rights and Freedoms. Meanwhile, across the border, U.S. courts echo this sentiment, consistently affirming that the middle finger is a protected expression under the First Amendment, even in the face of law enforcement.
So, the next time you feel the urge to give someone the bird—be it in frustration or jest—you can rest easy knowing that, legally speaking, you’re well within your rights. Just be prepared for the possible reactions; while the law may support you, the recipient of your gesture might not share your enthusiasm for the legalities involved!
Baker Newby LLP is dedicated to being the leading Fraser Valley law firm, delivering practical, effective legal solutions. We strive to serve with excellence, earning the trust of our clients, our community, and our peers.
